Steelers fans hoping for Aaron Rodgers news just got a reality check from Pat McAfee | NFL News

Aaron Rodgers‘ drama continues. The four-time MVP remains unsigned in free agency, and the lingering question isn’t just about if he’ll sign with the Steelers—but when. Fans and insiders alike are on edge as rumors swirl about Rodgers potentially making a headline-grabbing announcement in the most unexpected way: during a comedy-meets-football extravaganza at Pat McAfee’s “Big Night Aht” in Pittsburgh.

Pat McAfee addresses Steelers-Aaron Rodgers rumors

The buzz started brewing with Aaron Rodgers’ continued silence about his NFL future. While reports suggest that he’s already met with the Steelers and that a potential deal might already be on the table, the quarterback has yet to make anything official. This silence has only fueled speculation, especially since Rodgers has a long-standing tradition of using The Pat McAfee Show as his personal announcement platform.

Rodgers, a regular Tuesday guest during the NFL season, has previously used the show to break significant news—including the moment when he introduced Davante Adams after the star wideout joined the New York Jets. That history, combined with McAfee’s scheduled live show in Pittsburgh, has ignited a firestorm of fan theories suggesting that the “Big Night Aht” could double as a surprise reveal of Rodgers joining the Steelers.
But according to McAfee and Steelers insider Mark Kaboly, fans hoping for that dramatic moment may be setting themselves up for disappointment.
“If you’re going there to see Aaron Rodgers, I think you’re probably going to be disappointed,” Kaboly said in a recent radio appearance on 93.7 The Fan.
Even McAfee himself addressed the situation, adding humor to the rumors while trying to cool the frenzy: “That’s crazy. It’s hilarious to think about. I do appreciate that people think that is possible.”
Despite these denials, the timing and location of the event are enough to keep hope alive in the Steel City. After all, it wouldn’t be the first time Rodgers orchestrated a surprise appearance through his media connections. And if he were to make a major announcement, what better place than a high-energy live show in front of an NFL-obsessed crowd in Pittsburgh?
Still, McAfee tried to lay the rumors to rest once again during an appearance on Footbahlin with Ben Roethlisberger:
“There’s going to be a lot of surprises tomorrow night at Big Night AHT—Aaron Rodgers is not on the docket… I have not talked to Aaron Rodgers,” he said. “I think it would be a positive reaction at that particular show—but I haven’t talked to him in weeks, months at this point.”
Whether you believe McAfee or not, the speculation doesn’t seem to be going away anytime soon. Rodgers’ delay in making a decision is starting to create real consequences for the Steelers. With both Russell Wilson and Justin Fields off the table, Pittsburgh’s quarterback options are quickly narrowing—and the NFL Draft is just around the corner.
Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin has reportedly circled the beginning of training camp as a soft deadline for Rodgers to make his decision. But the longer this uncertainty lingers, the more pressure it puts on the team’s front office to explore alternatives. As more QB prospects are claimed in the draft or signed elsewhere, the window of opportunity might start to close.
Still, Rodgers isn’t obligated to rush. His stature in the league gives him the luxury of patience. For Steelers Nation, though, patience is running thin—and many are clinging to the hope that Wednesday night’s event might finally bring clarity.
Until Rodgers puts pen to paper, the speculation will continue. Whether or not he takes the stage in Pittsburgh, one thing is certain—the entire NFL world is watching, and the city of Pittsburgh is holding its collective breath.
Also Read: Steelers eye surprise move that could instantly please Aaron Rodgers by reuniting him with a Jordy Nelson clone